Should I have not been adopted?

Rainbow in the Appalachian Mountains(Virginia)
Should I have not been adopted? Who is to say? At different points of my life I have wondered why me and why was I adopted. There must be a bigger reason for me to be in America. I don’t know what the answer to those questions is and I think that there truly is no answer. Was it fate, destiny, or luck? Through this blog I have heard so many opinions about my adoption. I’ve been told that I need to call myself “sold” rather than adopted to I am not grateful enough to be adopted and also many thanks from people who say these posts are making a difference for them as adoptees and adoptive parents.
The opinions about me really don’t seem to matter. What does matter is that our story (my families and mine) be told. There is no possible way for strangers to know what any of us have been through.
As a stranger on the reading end of my stories you can only “imagine” what my mother Shanti went through when her first born baby girl disappeared never to return for 25 years or how my adoptive mother Shirley may have felt when told that the adoption she was involved with may have been done without my biological mother’s consent and there is no way for anyone to step in my shoes either and feel the loneliness, isolation and emptiness that I share with so many other adoptees.
Judgment is rampant when looking at someone else in our world. Why are we spending time judging when we could be learning and understanding how to make our world and lives better through compassion and love for each other?
My adoptive mother Shirley never discriminated on whom she would help. She helped everybody never taking a moment to think about his or her religion, race or how he or she got into his or her predicament. There were drug addicts to little old ladies that she embraced.
My mother Shanti doesn’t discriminate. She stops to pray at every church regardless of religion whether Catholic, Buddhist, Hindu, or Muslim.
Even as an adoptee with my experience, I do not feel I have the right or ability to judge whether someone is “better off” or not because they were adopted. Who is to say what is “better off” for an individual?
The matter of adoption is a deep and intricate subject, one that everyone has strong opinions on.
The facts are that I was adopted, it was done with carelessness, my adoptive parents did nothing wrong, my mother only trusted a friend, I am a product of circumstances, I love both of my families, and I will continue to tell my story in hopes that it helps somebody in even the smallest ways. It is the system that is broken and needs revamping. One of the biggest voids is understanding of the adoptee and their suffering that occurs without a foundation of familial background. We all need to know our ancestry and our families regardless of the situations we came from, it is only natural for humans to have this desire. Another problem are the legalities, who is really watching over these adoptions to make sure that they are done properly?
All of us affected by adoption are being called forth to help in our own little ways to make a change. There is no change with ignorance and complacency nor without acceptance.
Should I have been adopted is a waste of time to ask, it is my story but what I choose to do with this experience can be either an opportunity or pain and suffering. We adoptees have that choice, that is the opportunity. We didn’t have choice in the matter at the time of adoption and cannot change anything but we do have the choice now and we can make a difference.
© Pushpa Duncklee and Pushpa’s Blog, 2009. Unauthorized use and/or duplication of this material without express and written permission from this blog’s author and/or owner is strictly prohibited. Excerpts and links may be used, provided that full and clear credit is given to Pushpa Duncklee and Pushpa’s Blog with appropriate and specific direction to the original content.





As always Pushpa – BRAVO!!!!! Well said, another beautiful post from a beautiful person!
Maureen
April 27, 2009
I absolutely agree with you 100%~
Thank you for sharing this!
Miriam Gaenicke
April 30, 2009
I totally understand your conflict of emotions concerning your own adoption. I am that way myself. Of course, I am also not in reunion. Another story that has been told too many times. You got it right about judgment in the adoption world. It is harsh and unrelenting. I don’t understand it myself.
As far as who is watching over adoption, that is a good question. The states have privatized their foster care systems. The adoption industry regulates itself. Since the federal govt pays the states which in turn pays the agencies. This is just foster care. There is no serious regulation over adoption agencies in this country.
Amyadoptee
May 1, 2009
” We didn’t have choice in the matter at the time of adoption and cannot change anything but we do have the choice now and we can make a difference.”
I understand this sentiment, it is a difficult one for some adoptees to come to terms with and accept.
I think – in my experience – the reason why I personally have had such a hard time accepting it is that (to me) it’s almost like saying “So what? Bad things happened in the past but since we’re in the present, we can ignore whichever mistakes we made *because* we can’t change the past.”
Also I am one of the TRAs in contact/reunion, I often feel the effects of separation and the pain/joy of reunification. It is not so easy to just sit back and say “Well, what’s done is done and we must get over it and stop reflecting back on the past.”
Obviously that is the most logical answer and the most doable one, considering we indeed CAN’T change the past. But it’s a hard thing to accept at times because to move forward into the future, we often learn from our mistakes IN the past. :\
Mei-Ling
May 3, 2009
The Truth is people need to stop having opinions on it. I hate when someone here tells me, “you were so lucky to be adopted” really? Am i any luckier than that person having been born into a nice life? No. Everything is random, including people who had good lives in the first place, yes i am grateful for the life I have, but I hate seeing that same little twit who said that about me be a major bitch to her own parents, bc in her mind she doesn’t have to be grateful bc she deserves a nice life. Everyone should be grateful if they have a nice life. I think you are a wonderful person, Im glad to have found your blog.
Shweta
May 3, 2009
Pushpa, Your comments hit home. Although I’m not an adoptee, I am the daughter of a single teen mom whose father rejected me. Back then, there were still 2 parent homes, so I was the outsider and was constantly berated. I recently met my father after 32 years and the reunification was weird. I realized that all I wanted to know was if he were dead or alive. I didn’t really care about the relationship. The past is the past. All we can do is live in the present. Only God knows why we end up where we do. I do believe it makes us stronger! Thanks for sharing such difficult topics! You were meant to experience this adoption so it could shape you into the beautiful person you are today! Never forget that!
Maya
May 7, 2009
Pushpa: your comments are very insightful and correct, and much of what you say also applies to ‘bio’ children raised by their ‘biological’ parents.
No child (‘bio’ or adopted) chooses the circumstances of their birth or upbringing.
Many children in their ‘bio’ families also feel alienated, may be abused, or experience other evils.
We can all make a (hopefully positive) difference in someone’s life and try to do much better in the future, compared to what was done in the past (due to neglect, ignorance, or whatever).
S
May 19, 2009
From what I can understand from your posts, you are fortunate to have two families who love you dearly, and whom you love in return. Two women call themselves your mother, love you unconditionally and obviously taught you to be a caring, loving individual who cares deeply about justice in the world. We all suffer in life. No one has a perfect life without scars or pain. Of course things were done wrong. But in the end, you have an abundance of love. That can never be wrong. If you asked me for advice (and you did not) I would recommend counting your blessings, which would start with love.
SH
Sunny H
May 20, 2009